Culture

The lambs break their silence

A study of ancient bones shows that Early Neolithic sheep-breeders were faced with high levels of mortality among young animals in their herds. A statistical model, partly developed at Ludwig-Maximilians-Universitaet (LMU) in Munich, allowed the age distribution of the bones to be precisely determined.

In the 8th millennium BCE, early sheep-herders were already aware that the conditions under which their animals were housed had an impact on mortality rates among the lambs. This one result of a study researchers led by Nadja Pöllath (a curator at the State Collection for Anthropology and Palaeoanatomy in Munich), LMU zooarchaeologist Joris Peters (who is also the Director of the state collection) and LMU statistician Sevag Kevork have now taken a closer look at the bones of unborn and neonatal lambs, which form part of the collections studied by them. The material comes from the Early Neolithic site A??kl? Höyük, one of the largest and best investigated settlements from this period in Central Anatolia. The site was occupied from 8350 to around 7300 BCE, and the study reveals that the life expectancy of newborn lambs gradually increased over this timespan. The researchers attribute this finding to improvements in husbandry of the herds, which enabled a larger proportion of neonates to survive the nursing period, and be let out to graze the nearby pastures.

The archaeological remains that have come to light at A??kl? Höyük provide valuable information, not only on its domestic architecture and cultural practices, but also on the surrounding vegetation and the diets of the people and animals living in the area. Moreover, it sheds light on the development of agriculture and animal husbandry during the Early Neolithic period. The finds indicate that, in the settlement's earliest phase, its inhabitants still obtained their meat mainly from hunting. Later on, however, domesticated animals - primarily sheep - supplied much of the animal protein consumed. The discovery of compacted dung layers within the settlement indicates that sheep were kept for longer periods within the boundaries of the settlement.

A new analysis of the age distribution of the animal bones found at A??kl? Höyük illustrates the problems with which early sheep-herders were confronted - and on how they learned to mitigate them. Most of the conventional approaches used to determine the exact age at which the animals died focus on teeth. However, such methods are not sufficiently sensitive to enable researchers to reliably differentiate between developmental stages in very young animals - in this case, sheep covering the age range from the fetus to newborns and juveniles.

In order to determine the ages of fetuses and lambs as accurately as possible, the researchers developed a new statistical model. They first analyzed the morphology of the humerus or upper-arm bone in a sample of modern sheep breeds, based on material kept in anatomical reference collections in the US, the UK, Spain, Portugal and Germany, and used the results to construct a comparative model for Neolithic sheep. In this way, the age at death of the bones of lambs from A??kl? Höyük could be precisely determined. "Our analyses were of great value in enabling us to narrow down the range of possible ages of death in fetuses and lambs," says Nadja Pöllath. "We now have a better understanding of the difficulties that early herders faced in the early phases of sheep domestication in A??kl? Höyük." Infections were the primary causes of early mortality, together with malnutrition and dietary deficiencies. In addition, the animals were kept under overcrowded conditions. When they were subsequently let out to grass their health improved. The zooarchaeological data also suggest that, towards the end of the occupation of A??kl? Höyük, fetal mortality fell and more lambs survived. Prof. Peters concludes: "Our research thus proves for the first time that learning by doing determined the early phase of livestock farming in the 9th and 8th millennia BCE."

Credit: 
Ludwig-Maximilians-Universität München

Telehealth consults increased more than 50-fold among privately insured working-age patients during first phase of the pandemic

A study co-authored by researchers at the Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health found that telehealth consults among privately insured working-age patients accounted for almost 24 percent of outpatient consults with health care providers during the early phase of the pandemic, March to June 2020, up from less than 0.3 percent during the same period in 2019.

The dramatic shift occurred as many medical practices halted or curtailed in-person office hours and patients stayed away from doctor's offices out of fear of transmission during the early months of the pandemic. At the same time, insurance companies and the federal government relaxed policies around telehealth to meet demand for remote medical consults via internet video or telephone.

The study was published online March 23 in JAMA Network Open.

For their study, researchers from Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health and Blue Health Intelligence®, an independent licensee of the Blue Cross Blue Shield Association, analyzed anonymized claims data drawn from 36.6 million private insurance plan members who were of working age and continuously enrolled during the study period. The claims data for the study were provided by Blue Health Intelligence.

A total of 15 million telehealth claims were submitted during the March to June 2020 study period, with nearly three-quarters involving video support (74.4 percent) and fewer than one in ten occurring via phone (9.2 percent). Just over 3 percent (3.3 percent) were conducted either by email or chat while 13.1 percent were unspecified.

Mental health consults were far more likely to take place virtually--with 46.1 percent taking place via telehealth. By comparison, 22.1 percent of medical consults were virtual. In COVID-19 "hot spot" states--those with a COVID-19 prevalence at least 1.5 times the national average--36 percent of all consults were telehealth versus 21.6 percent in areas with lower COVID-19 prevalence. The study also found that the greater the COVID-19 prevalence in a specific ZIP code, the higher the use of telehealth.

"Telehealth has been around for a long time, but the recent increase has been enormous," says the study's lead author, Jonathan Weiner, DrPH, co-director of the Center for Population Health Information Technology and professor in the Department of Health Policy and Management at the Bloomberg School. "These findings will not only help doctors and other clinicians plan for the future, they will also guide policymakers and technology companies, especially as we learn more about the challenges of accessing telehealth among older patients, the uninsured, and low-income patients."

About a quarter of consults, 24.2 percent, in urban areas were via telehealth. This compared to only 14.2 percent of visits for members who lived in more rural settings. Age and number of chronic diseases were associated with more frequent telehealth consults, with individuals age 18 to 49 and those with more than two chronic conditions using telehealth the most.

The study also found that overall total medical care costs, including hospitalizations, dropped 15 percent, from $358 to $306 per person per month, from 2019 to 2020. Persons with at least one COVID-19-related consult in 2020 had more than three times the medical costs compared to those with no COVID-19-related services--$1,701 per member per month versus $544, a difference of $1,157.

Overall, the researchers found that in-person, outpatient visits decreased by 37 percent, from an average of 1.63 visits per enrollee during the three-month 2019 study period to an average of 1.02 visits per enrollee in 2020. However, since telehealth visits filled much of the gap, the total combined in-person and virtual encounter rate dropped only 18 percent between 2019 and 2020.

For persons with at least one COVID-19-related insurance claim, including screening and care, the average number of in-person and telehealth consults were about 30 percent higher than the average number of claims for persons with no COVID-19-related visit. One-quarter of COVID-19-related consults were via telehealth versus 23.5 percent for non-COVID-19-related consults.

"Even though some of our findings are unique to the COVID-19 era, we need to consider what telehealth will look like beyond the pandemic," says Weiner. "We will need to continue to assess and modify telehealth strategies to maximize value during this digital age, particularly given the challenges of the digital divide across social and geographic lines."

Credit: 
Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health

Corals may need their predators' poop

image: Chaetodon lunulatus, a coral predator photographed in Mo'orea, French Polynesia, in October 2020. Rice University marine biologists discovered that the feces of coral-eating fish in Mo'orea contain high concentrations of live symbiotic algae that coral depend upon.

Image: 
Photo by Alex Veglia/Rice University

HOUSTON - (March 23, 2021) - Fish that dine on corals may pay it forward with poop.

It's an unexpected twist on coral reef symbiosis, said Rice University marine biologist Adrienne Correa, whose lab discovered coral predator feces are jam-packed with living symbiotic algae that corals depend on for survival. The discovery confirms that poop from coral-eating fish is an important environmental source of symbiotic dinoflagellate algae on coral reefs.

Correa said coral-eating predators are typically thought of as biting and weakening reef structures, thereby generating hiding spaces for other organisms and, ultimately, beach sand. In contrast, grazing fish that crop down bushy algae get the limelight for helping reefs maintain healthy coral cover.

"The message is, 'Move over grazers, it's not just you helping maintain coral dominance. These coral-eating fishes are probably helping too by spreading beneficial coral symbionts,'" she said.

Rice doctoral student Carsten Grupstra, lead author of the study in Animal Microbiome, said, "This tells us we don't really know all of the interactions that are happening on coral reefs, and some species may be important for coral reef conservation in ways that we haven't imagined."

In exchange for a sheltered life, dinoflagellates nourish their hosts by sharing the food they photosynthesize. Millions of symbionts live in each coral, but some corals aren't born with dinoflagellates. They acquire them as babies.

"When many baby corals settle on the reef bottom, they have to get their symbionts from the environment," Correa said. "We've seen symbionts in the water and sediments and on big bushy algae on reefs, but we haven't really looked at how those microorganisms get to all those places."

In thinking about ways symbionts might be distributed on reefs, Grupstra, Correa, graduate student Lauren Howe-Kerr and undergraduate Kristen Rabbitt were inspired by studies of pollinating insects and birds that pass beneficial bacteria between flowering plants. Like pollinating bees that visit many flowers in a single flight, coral-eating fish constantly crisscross reefs and interact with many corals each day.

"Most of them take small bites of adult corals and don't kill the colonies they're eating," Grupstra explained.

During an expedition to the Mo'orea Coral Reef Long-term Ecological Research station in French Polynesia, Grupstra, Howe-Kerr, Rabbitt and Correa followed fish that ate different amounts of coral and algae. Using underwater clipboards, they made note of what the fish ate and where and how often they defecated. Grupstra also gathered samples of predator and grazer poop to examine in the lab.

"I left some samples in the window sill for a couple of weeks in Mo'orea" he said. "Later, when I started looking at them (under a microscope), I found tons of symbionts. A lot of them were swimming around and some were dividing."

The sheer number of live symbionts was both unexpected and potentially important in the larger picture of reef ecology, Correa said. While symbionts had previously been reported in feces from a limited number of coral predators, it was unclear how many of them were alive and potentially useful to corals. Her group found high concentrations of live symbionts in the feces of a diverse group of coral predators. For example, the Rice team estimated that two species at the Mo'orea research station, Chaetodon ornatissimus and Chaetodon reticulatus, each spread about 100 million live symbionts per day over an area of reef approximately the size of six parking spaces.

"This expands how we can think about the roles of coral-eating fishes on reefs," Correa said. "They don't just break up reef frameworks. They also disperse symbionts that corals and other organisms need."

The knowledge that predator poop creates "hotspots" of live symbiotic dinoflagellates on reefs raises questions about whether and how coral use them. Correa's team has planned a series of experiments on both juvenile and stressed adult corals to determine how readily they absorb beneficial symbionts from the poop.

She said many questions remain about how and how frequently corals take up symbionts from the environment. For example, marine biologists widely agree that many coral babies get their symbionts from the environment, but it is unclear how often adults do this and under what conditions. Better understanding symbiont uptake could lead to new methods to help reefs recover from stress-induced "bleaching."

Bleaching occurs when stressed corals expel their symbionts en masse, frequently leaving corals colorless, as the name implies. Bleaching events are increasingly common due to climate change. While some corals never recover from bleaching, others do, which raises the question of how bleached corals repopulate their symbiont communities. Grupstra and Correa are conducting research to find out whether contact with coral predator feces can improve bleaching recovery rates and long-term coral health.

Credit: 
Rice University

A divided visual field

image: Measurements have shown how the hummingbird hawkmoth uses optic flow for flight control and orientation.

Image: 
(Image: Anna Stoeckl / University of Wuerzburg)

Hummingbird hawkmoths are small insects that hover in the air like hummingbirds when drinking nectar from flowers. Dr. Anna Stöckl from the Biocentre of the Julius-Maximilians-Universität (JMU) Würzburg in Bavaria, Germany, is studying the visual performance of these insects. Dr. Stöckl and her doctoral student Ronja Bigge now present their latest findings in the journal Current Biology.

"To control their flight, hummingbird hawkmoths rely on optic flow in the lower half of their visual field," Ronja Bigge explains. Optic flow is the relative motion that the surrounding image casts on the animals' retinas when they fly. We experience this phenomenon ourselves when travelling by train - the landscape passing by the train windows allows us to estimate our speed, for example.

For hawkmoths, the optic flow also provides information about their own movement. It helps them to control the straightness and speed of their flight. The JMU researchers have now shown with outdoor measurements that the optic flow components parallel to the direction of flight are always strongest below the hawkmoths' body. This is where the insects see meadows, gardens and streets that provide a varied texture. For flight control, what happens in the lower visual field is therefore the most reliable parameter.

Previously unknown behaviour discovered

"Surprisingly, we were able to show that the hawkmoths displayed a completely different and novel behaviour when we presented them with visual textures in the upper half of their visual field," says Anna Stöckl.

The animals then oriented themselves along prominent contours in the patterns. Thus, they did not use the visual information for flight control, but for orientation - although the visual patterns were exactly the same as the ones that were previously presented in the lower half of their visual field.

"Our optical measurements in natural habitats showed a comparable relationship: high-contrast structures that can be used for orientation occur primarily in the upper half of the visual field," says the JMU researcher. These are, for example, the silhouettes of treetops or bushes that form a strong contrast with the sky.

Visual field is divided in two

The conclusion of the Würzburg biologists: "The flight control system and the orientation system of the hummingbird hawkmoth divide the visual field among themselves and focus on the respective area that provides the most reliable information in their natural habitats."

In other words, it is not only important what the animals see, but also where they see it.

Credit: 
University of Würzburg

"Metamorphosis" is needed in entrepreneurship and management, pioneering economist says

image: Rotary Management principle, evolved as ZIPF, in the 90s by Prof. Milan Zeleny

Image: 
Milan Zeleny

Amsterdam, NL, March 22, 2021 - The COVID-19 pandemic has had a profound impact on our world, with disequilibrium, uncertainty, and human suffering making it difficult to envision a human, societal and individual future. Milan Zeleny, PhD, Professor Emeritus of Management Systems, Fordham University, New York, NY, USA, and world-recognized authority on decision making, productivity, knowledge management, and more recently the corporation as a living organism, says that "COVID-19 is rapidly changing from a cause to one of the symptoms of an increasingly unhinged world."

Writing in the journal Human Systems Management, published by IOS Press, Prof. Zeleny discusses the consequences of disequilibrium across business, political, and other systems and proposes new models that may help systems evolve to succeed in the future.

'Accelerating speed of change is a natural evolutionary phenomenon, originally noticeable over many generations and now emerging within a single generation. It is the most important causal factor of our disequilibrium, yet it is virtually ignored or misunderstood by science and philosophy," notes Prof. Zeleny. "The faster the new emerges, the more of the old that must be abandoned. This leads to resistance, political disruptions, and populist defense of the status quo. New and reliable Evolutionary Economics [a name coined by Prof. Zeleny for this new science] must be recognized."

Economic differences between nations are fast disappearing, while inequalities in terms of local and reginal economies are widening even faster. "Well balanced regional and local economies are the only assurance of a well-balanced country or nation as a whole. New and lasting improvements can emerge by not ignoring, but by respecting and enhancing natural evolutionary tendencies," explains Prof. Zeleny.

Other pressures Prof. Zeleny explores include conflicts between state intervention and self-organized natural response; an imbalance between rates of accepting the new and abandoning old; conflicts between the man-made and the naturally occurring world; and emerging needs for multidisciplinary education thinking, research, and action.

The most significant challenges to overcome include the protection of old paradigms, overcoming tendencies towards preserving status quo, or returning to the old "normal," especially for political reasons.

Prof. Zeleny reviews the management system concept he developed, known as the Zeleny ZIPF, or Rotary. It rotates and revolves around customer satisfaction to drive innovation, improve processes, and achieve financial success. He also draws on the experience of the Bata Management System, now celebrating (as BSO in India) its 126th anniversary, which was organized to behave as a living organism: learning, adjusting, and self-organizing.

Prof. Zeleny asserts that in a rapidly evolving environment, additional cultural traits should be acquired within a properly run ZIPF or a similar rotary management system. For example, rapid change does not allow for a traditional strategy; you have to handle the future. He calls this the Strategy of the first step. You take the first step, evaluate the impacts, and then take the next first step. It is like every day is the Day 1!

To achieve equilibrium in human systems, Prof. Zeleny introduces the idea of Integrated Productive Environments (IPE), in which regions, localities, and communities are allowed their economic independence, self-sufficiency, entrepreneurship, and innovative originality. Such independence and self-determination, he says, will lead to cooperation, coordination, and local exchanges of specific knowledge products and services, in the interest of continued self-enhancement.

The highest IPE would be a complete town: productive, flexible, modular, fully equipped to provide food, products, and services, all in the closest proximity to regional or local customers. The first such IPE town was the Bata-Zlín in Moravia, which was "exported" all over the world, and is still functional even today.

"Such orientation requires competent cooperation of many individuals, companies, and institutions at multilayered cultural, professional and knowledge levels," says Prof. Zeleny. "It is this kind of deep cooperation that is needed to restore regional and local equilibrium."

IPEs are also needed in education, government, healthcare, defense, and environmental protection. "As we are abandoning the old to embrace the new, we cannot remain the narrow specialists or 'experts.' We have to become multidisciplinary polymaths," he concludes.

Prof. Zeleny is the Founding Editor of Human Systems Management, which is celebrating its 40th anniversary in 2021. His article is the first in a new section of the journal, "Strategic revival of Human Systems Management." Editor-in-Chief Nada Trunk Širca, PhD, International School for Social and Business Studies, Euro-Mediterranean University, University of Primorska, Slovenia, explains that articles in the new section will address how the concepts raised by Prof. Zeleny can be woven into human systems management research and applications. "The journal will continue as a self-renewing, evolving entity, open to new paradigms, new technologies, timely adaptations, and trailblazing new authors from around the world," she says.

Credit: 
IOS Press

UNM study: As more are vaccinated, it makes economic sense to gradually open the economy

image: Francesco Sorrentino, associate professor of mechanical engineering, University of New Mexico

Image: 
UNM School of Engineering

A University of New Mexico research team conducted a data analysis that has found that as a larger portion of the population gets vaccinated against COVID-19, it becomes economically advantageous to start relaxing social distancing measures and open businesses.

Francesco Sorrentino, associate professor of mechanical engineering, is lead author of "Data-driven Optimized Control of the COVID-19 Epidemics," published March 22 in Scientific Reports.

Co-authors of the study are Afroza Shirin of the Department of Mechanical Engineering and the Department of Electrical and Computer Engineering, and Yen Ting Lin, a staff scientist of the Information Science Group in the Computer, Computational and Statistical Sciences Division at Los Alamos National Laboratory.

The study looked at data from four metropolitan statistical areas (MSAs) within the United States: Seattle, New York City, Los Angeles and Houston from January 21 to July 8, 2020. The four cities were chosen because they have had divergent trends with the virus (Seattle and New York City were early hotspots, while Los Angeles and Houston peaked in the summer).

Sorrentino said that while the findings perhaps may seem obvious, they are significant because the model is inferred and parametrized by regional new case reports and could potentially help guide policy decisions as more businesses, schools and other organizations ponder when and how to reopen during the pandemic.

"Our work is quantitative, so it can hopefully offer some evidence that shows the vaccines are going to allow us to loosen social distancing measures, including opening businesses," he said. "It provides a measure of hope as we go forward and increase the percentage of citizens who are vaccinated."

He points out that the study was looking at just the numbers, what he calls an "optimization problem," to determine the economic cost of keeping many businesses closed or at reduced capacity. Sorrentino said the study defined economic impact by the extent that a city's economy was closed -- businesses like restaurants, gyms, salons and airports that would lose business without people's physical presence. The study took into account both the costs associated with quarantining (which requires supervision costs as well as costs due to lowered productivity) as well as social distancing (which incurs costs only due to productivity).

"We did not look at this mainly from a public health standpoint. We were looking at the economic impact of the pandemic, which we attempted to minimize while in the presence of constraints relevant to the public health domain, such as suppressing the number of infected individuals below a threshold over the course of a few months" he said. "But our model shows that even before we achieve herd immunity, we can relax social distancing compared to the situation prior to immunization."

Sorrentino said there are several other caveats to the study. For instance, the analysis took place before the virus variants were a factor in the United States, so that variable is not taken into account.

The analysis looked at Seattle, beginning on December 14, 2020, when the vaccine was first being administered. Even with this limited data, the effect of vaccinations was dramatic, impacting the so-called "optimal control solution." The study computed these optimal solutions under many different conditions.

"While the optimal interventions would vary depending on a number of factors, we always saw that a gradual relaxation of social distancing was possible after roughly 10% of the population got vaccinated," he said.

After just 20 days, the trend was becoming clear when comparing with the case in which the effects of vaccinations were not incorporated in the model.

"With even just a small percentage of the population being vaccinated, much less social distancing was optimal, so it can be assumed that the effect from increased vaccination efforts will be even more robust," he said.

Sorrentino emphasizes also that everyone should continue to follow the current policy and health guidelines, and that the relaxing of social distancing should adhere to these guidelines and be gradual. And of course, that guidance may change, based on the rates of spread of the virus and the variants.

Sorrentino has conducted extensive research in the area of control theory and synchronization using mathematical models. Last year, he was awarded the National Institutes of Health Trailblazer Award from the National Institute of Biomedical Imaging and Bioengineering for a research project that could improve the way drugs for diseases are timed and delivered to patients.

Credit: 
University of New Mexico

Fruit fly egg takes an active hand in its own growth, highlighting parallels to mammals

image: Bidirectional communication between the nurse cells and the oocyte (one larger cell). Nurse cells send Dap mRNA towards the oocyte (white arrows). In return, the oocyte sends Dap protein towards the nurse cells (yellow arrows). By the end stage of development (largest cells), the nurse cells no longer receive Dap protein from the oocyte.

Image: 
(c) Simons Foundation

A cast of so-called 'nurse cells' surrounds and supports the growing fruit fly egg during development, supplying the egg -- or 'oocyte' -- with all the nutrients and molecules it needs to thrive. Long viewed as passive in this process, the Drosophila egg actually plays an active role not only in its own growth, but also in the growth of the surrounding nurse cells, Princeton University researchers report on March 21 in Developmental Cell.

"Here we show an example of bidirectional communication -- a dialogue -- between different cells. The egg is taking an active hand in controlling its own feeding by these supporting cells," says Stanislav Shvartsman, head of the developmental dynamics group within the Flatiron Institute's Center for Computational Biology and professor of molecular biology at Princeton. The discovery of bidirectional communication in fruit flies has implications for understanding development in mammals, in which the egg is also nursed by surrounding cells.

The research was led by Shvartsman and Elizabeth Gavis, also professor of molecular biology; Caroline Doherty was lead author, and Rocky Diegmiller and Manisha Kapasiawala contributed to the study.

In early development, four cell divisions give rise to the 16 connected cells that make up the Drosophila germline cyst, the first structure formed during gamete development. One of these becomes the egg; the other 15 cells support the egg's dramatic growth by supplying it with vast quantities of nutrients that travel via intricate microtubule networks, and through cytoplasmic connections between the egg and nurse cells. Until now, scientists have viewed the oocyte as merely a passive recipient. The observation of groups of nurse cells that vary in size according to their distance from the oocyte led the researchers to suspect that some type of cell-cell communication occurs, says Shvartsman. Since cell size and cell cycle are tightly correlated, investigating the factors influencing the nurse cell cycle was the clear next step, says Doherty.

Researchers honed in on a protein called Dap (short for 'Da capo', meaning 'from the top'), which is known to influence cell cycle progression. Nurse cells supply the oocyte with RNA molecules needed to make the Dap protein. Doherty noticed that oocyte-manufactured Dap protein appeared in the nurse cells, at a rate suggesting that it diffused from the oocyte. After fusing a tiny Dap-recognizing antibody (called a nanobody) to a protein that could trap Dap within the egg, Doherty saw a decrease of the Dap level in the nurse cells. Together, these experiments showed that once the egg makes Dap, it diffuses to the very nurse cells that donated Dap RNA, providing the first evidence for two-way oocyte-nurse cell communication in fruit flies. "It was so exciting to see the oocyte is communicating with the nurse cells -- this is something scientists hadn't considered," says Gavis. Further, the egg communicates via Dap, which controls the nurse cell cycles, which in turn influence the egg's growth. So, in a feedback loop, "the egg is controlling the growth of the cells that load it with nutrients and information" says Doherty.

To better understand the logic of this bidirectional communication, researchers modeled the system as a network of coupled oscillators: models based on the biochemical clocks that drive cell cycles. The model underscored the role of a diffusible cell cycle inhibitor (like Dap) in creating a hierarchy of cell sizes similar to what is observed in Drosophila. Importantly, it also showed the oscillators must be tuned within a specific range to establish a feedback loop that gives the egg the right amount of sustenance for proper growth and viability. "These 16 cells make up one of the simplest systems in which we can dissect this sophisticated feedback loop," says Shvartsman.

As a next step, Doherty plans to investigate signaling between the oocyte-nurse cells cyst and the sheet of follicle cells that surrounds it. "These two tissue types need to grow together, and later, the follicle cells that stay over the nurse cells stretch out. Is this positioning necessary to properly stretch the follicle cells?" Doherty asks. "We might move from a dialogue to a conversation between these three cell types," adds Shvartsman.

The discovery of bidirectional communication in fruit fly development points to the notion of universal mechanisms at play in biology, as back-and-forth communication between the oocyte and supporting cells is also seen in mammals. "This study opens up the possibility to discover many more instances of this kind of cellular crosstalk in development," says Yukiko Yamashita, professor of biology at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology. Although previous work on mammals focused on the egg's control of the metabolism of surrounding cells, this study may spur researchers to investigate the egg's impact on cell cycle regulation in mammals, says Francesca Duncan, co-director of the Center for Reproductive Science at the Feinberg School of Medicine at Northwestern University. "This work solidifies the parallels between fruit flies and mammals," adds Gavis.

Credit: 
Simons Foundation

A strong coffee half an hour before exercising increases fat-burning

image: The scientists have demonstrated that consuming caffeine (about 3 mg/kg or the equivalent of a strong coffee) half an hour before aerobic exercise significantly increases fat-burning

Image: 
University of Granada

Scientists from the Department of Physiology of the University of Granada (UGR) have shown that caffeine (about 3 mg/kg, the equivalent of a strong coffee) ingested half an hour before aerobic exercise significantly increases the rate of fat-burning. They also found that if the exercise is performed in the afternoon, the effects of the caffeine are more marked than in the morning.

In their study, published in the Journal of the International Society of Sports Nutrition, the researchers aimed to determine whether caffeine--one of the most commonly-consumed ergogenic substances in the world to improve sports performance--actually does increase oxidation or "burning" of fat during exercise. Despite the fact that its consumption in the form of supplements is very common, the scientific evidence for its beneficial claims is scarce.

"The recommendation to exercise on an empty stomach in the morning to increase fat oxidation is commonplace. However, this recommendation may be lacking a scientific basis, as it is unknown whether this increase is due to exercising in the morning or due to going without food for a longer period of time," explains the lead author of this research, Francisco José Amaro-Gahete of the UGR's Department of Physiology.

A total of 15 men (mean age, 32) participated in the research, completing an exercise test four times at seven-day intervals. Subjects ingested 3 mg/kg of caffeine or a placebo at 8am and 5pm (each subject completed the tests in all four conditions in a random order). The conditions prior to each exercise test (hours elapsed since last meal, physical exercise, or consumption of stimulant substances) were strictly standardized, and fat oxidation during exercise was calculated accordingly.

Maximum fat oxidation

"The results of our study showed that acute caffeine ingestion 30 minutes before performing an aerobic exercise test increased maximum fat oxidation during exercise regardless of the time of day," explains Francisco J. Amaro. The existence of a diurnal variation in fat oxidation during exercise was confirmed, the values ??being higher in the afternoon than in the morning for equal hours of fasting.

These results also show that caffeine increases fat oxidation during morning exercise in a similar way to that observed without caffeine intake in the afternoon.

In summary, the findings of this study suggest that the combination of acute caffeine intake and aerobic exercise performed at moderate intensity in the afternoon provides the optimal scenario for people seeking to increase fat-burning during physical exercise.

Credit: 
University of Granada

Fans prefer teams that built success over time more than with purchased super

LAWRENCE -- When a franchise buys a superstar like Tom Brady or LeBron James, the team tends to win more games. But do the fans follow? How much team loyalty is purchased along with an expensive star? Maybe not as much as some owners might hope -- in the NBA Finals between the Miami Heat and San Antonio Spurs, many fans expressed their dislike of the "bought" Miami team.

In a new paper published in the peer-reviewed Journal of Applied Social Psychology, researchers at the University of Kansas asked over 1,500 Americans how much they liked teams that purchased excellence and compared that with liking teams that built excellence from the ground up.

"People reliably preferred the 'built' teams and slighted the 'bought' teams," said lead author Omri Gillath, professor of psychology at KU. "This was true of sports teams -- even if they didn't know them, such as New Zealand rugby teams -- and work teams such as a squad of lawyers."

In each of five studies, people were willing to root more for the teams built over time than those assembled from free agency and deep-pocketed owners. People preferred teams of lawyers built with time and patience over those inviting in celebrities to shine and impress others.

This preference is reliable and strong. What makes the difference?

"Fans appreciate the effort and commitment required to build a team from the ground up," said co-author Christian Crandall, professor of psychology at KU. "Hard work is a central American value, and it certainly applies to work and sports -- everyone loves a winner, but even more so when the backstory is based on perspiration and determination."

Potential fans thought a gradually built team would show more teamwork, operating smoothly together as a team. The cohesion was a plus, but it was not as important as seeing hard work in building a team.

Fans prefer the teams who develop their players, invest in them and cultivate their skills.

"This explains part of the appeal of winning teams and part of the appeal of faithful fans of teams that work, struggle and manage to eke out just a few wins each season," Gillath said. "It could also help explain people's endorsement of Cinderella teams in competitions like March Madness. People love to see 'unknown' teams who work hard beat highly ranked teams with top one-and-done recruits."

Credit: 
University of Kansas

Nanobiomaterial boosts neuronal growth in mice with spinal cord injuries

image: Researchers from the Department of Orthopedics of Tongji Hospital have successfully used a nanobiomaterial called layered double hydroxide (LDH) to inhibit the inflammatory environment surrounding spinal cord injuries in mice, accelerating regeneration of neurons and reconstruction of the neural circuit in the spine.

Image: 
Liming Cheng, Rongrong Zhu, Department of Orthopedics, Tongji Hospital of Tongji University

Researchers from the Department of Orthopedics of Tongji Hospital at Tongji University in Shanghai have successfully used a nanobiomaterial called layered double hydroxide (LDH) to inhibit the inflammatory environment surrounding spinal cord injuries in mice, accelerating regeneration of neurons and reconstruction of the neural circuit in the spine. The researchers were also able to identify the underlying genetic mechanism by which LDH works. This understanding should allow further modification of the therapy which, in combination with other elements, could finally produce a comprehensive, clinically applicable system for spinal cord injury relief in humans.

The research appears in the American Chemical Society journal ACS Nano on February 2.

There is no effective treatment for spinal cord injuries, which are always accompanied by death of neurons, breakage of axons, or nerve fibers, and inflammation. Even though new neural stem cells continue to be generated by the body, this inflammatory microenvironment (the immediate, small-scale conditions at the injury site) severely hinders regeneration of neurons and axons. Worse still, the prolonged activation of immune cells in this area also results in secondary lesions of the nervous system, in turn preventing the stems cells from differentiating themselves into new cell types.

If this aggressive immune response at the injury site could be moderated, there is the possibility that neural stem cells could begin differentiation and neural regeneration could occur.

Image title: Nanobiomaterial boosts neuronal growth in mice

Image caption: Researchers from the Department of Orthopedics of Tongji Hospital have successfully used a nanobiomaterial called layered double hydroxide (LDH) to inhibit the inflammatory environment surrounding spinal cord injuries in mice, accelerating regeneration of neurons and reconstruction of the neural circuit in the spine.

Image credit: Liming Cheng, Rongrong Zhu, Department of Orthopedics, Tongji Hospital of Tongji University

Image usage restrictions: News organizations may use or redistribute this image, with proper attribution, as part of news coverage of this paper only.

In recent years, a raft of novel nano-scale biomaterials -- natural or synthetic materials that interact with biological systems -- have been designed to assist activation of neural stem cells, along with their mobilization and differentiation. Some of these "nanocomposites" are capable of delivering drugs to the injury site and accelerate neuronal regeneration. These nanocomposites are especially attractive for spinal cord treatment due to their low toxicity. However, few have any ability to inhibit or moderate the immune reaction at the site, and so do not tackle the underlying problem. Moreover, the underlying mechanisms of how they work remains unclear.

Nanolayered double hydroxide (LDH) is a kind of clay with many interesting biological properties relevant to spinal cord injuries, including good biocompatibility (ability to avoid rejection by the body), safe biodegradation (breakdown and removal of the molecules after application), and excellent anti-inflammatory capability. LDH has already been widely explored in biomedical engineering with respect to immune response regulation, but mainly in the field of anti-tumor therapy.

"These properties made LDH a really promising candidate for the creation of a much more bene?cial microenvironment for spinal cord injury recovery," says Rongrong Zhu of the
Department of Orthopedics of Tongji Hospital, first author of the study.

Under the leadership of Liming Cheng, corresponding author of the study, the research team transplanted the LDH into the injury site of mice, and found that the nanobiomaterial had signi?cantly accelerated neural stem cells migration, neural di?erentiation, activation of channels for neuron excitation, and induction of action potential (nerve impulse) activation. The mice were also found to enjoy significantly improved locomotive behavior compared to the control group of mice. In addition, when the LDH was combined with Neurotrophin-3 (NT3), a protein that encourages the growth and differentiation of new neurons, the mice enjoyed even better recovery effects than the LDH on its own. In essence, the NT3 boosts neuronal development while the LDH creates an environment where that development is allowed to thrive.

Then, via transcriptional profiling, or analysis of gene expression of thousands of genes at once, the researchers were able to identify how the LDH performs its assistance. They found that once LDH is attached to cell membranes, it provokes greater activation of the "transforming growth factor-β receptor 2" (TGFBR2) gene, decreasing production of the white blood cells that enhance inflammation and increasing production of the white blood cells that inhibit inflammation. Upon application of a chemical that inhibits TGFBR2, they found the beneficial effects were reversed.

The understanding of how LDH performs these effects should now allow the researchers to tweak the therapy to enhance its performance and to finally create a comprehensive therapeutic system for spinal cord injuries--combining these biomaterials with neurotrophic factors like NT3-that can be used in clinical application on people.

Credit: 
Department of Orthopedics, Tongji Hospital of Tongji University

New evidence in search for the mysterious Denisovans

image: Replica of the Sangiran 17 Homo erectus cranium from Java.

Image: 
Photo supplied by the Trustees of the Natural History Museum.

An international group of researchers led by the University of Adelaide has conducted a comprehensive genetic analysis and found no evidence of interbreeding between modern humans and the ancient humans known from fossil records in Island Southeast Asia. They did find further DNA evidence of our mysterious ancient cousins, the Denisovans, which could mean there are major discoveries to come in the region.

In the study published in Nature Ecology and Evolution, the researchers examined the genomes of more than 400 modern humans to investigate the interbreeding events between ancient humans and modern human populations who arrived at Island Southeast Asia 50,000-60,000 years ago.

In particular, they focused on detecting signatures that suggest interbreeding from deeply divergent species known from the fossil record of the area.

The region contains one of the richest fossil records (from at least 1.6 million years) documenting human evolution in the world. Currently there are three distinct ancient humans recognised from the fossil record in the area: Homo erectus, Homo floresiensis (known as Flores Island hobbits) and Homo luzonensis.

These species are known to have survived until approximately 50,000-60,000 years ago in the cases of Homo floresiensis and Homo luzonensis, and approximately 108,000 years for Homo erectus, which means they may have overlapped with the arrival of modern human populations.

The results of the study showed no evidence of interbreeding. Nevertheless, the team were able to confirm previous results showing high levels of Denisovan ancestry in the region.

Lead author and ARC Research Associate from the University of Adelaide Dr João Teixeira, said: "In contrast to our other cousins the Neanderthals, which have an extensive fossil record in Europe, the Denisovans are known almost solely from the DNA record. The only physical evidence of Denisovan existence has been a finger bone and some other fragments found in a cave in Siberia and, more recently, a piece of jaw found in the Tibetan Plateau."

"We know from our own genetic records that the Denisovans mixed with modern humans who came out of Africa 50,000-60,000 years ago both in Asia, and as the modern humans moved through Island Southeast Asia on their way to Australia.

"The levels of Denisovan DNA in contemporary populations indicates that significant interbreeding happened in Island Southeast Asia.

"The mystery then remains, why haven't we found their fossils alongside the other ancient humans in the region? Do we need to re-examine the existing fossil record to consider other possibilities?"

Co-author Chris Stringer of the Natural History Museum in London added:

"While the known fossils of Homo erectus, Homo floresiensis and Homo luzonensis might seem to be in the right place and time to represent the mysterious 'southern Denisovans', their ancestors were likely to have been in Island Southeast Asia at least 700,000 years ago. Meaning their lineages are too ancient to represent the Denisovans who, from their DNA, were more closely related to the Neanderthals and modern humans."

Co-author Prof Kris Helgen, Chief Scientist and Director of the Australian Museum Research Institute, said: "These analyses provide an important window into human evolution in a fascinating region, and demonstrate the need for more archaeological research in the region between mainland Asia and Australia."

Helgen added: "This research also illuminates a pattern of 'megafaunal' survival which coincides with known areas of pre-modern human occupation in this part of the world. Large animals that survive today in the region include the Komodo Dragon, the Babirusa (a pig with remarkable upturned tusks), and the Tamaraw and Anoas (small wild buffalos).

"This hints that long-term exposure to hunting pressure by ancient humans might have facilitated the survival of the megafaunal species in subsequent contacts with modern humans. Areas without documented pre-modern human occurrence, like Australia and New Guinea, saw complete extinction of land animals larger than humans over the past 50,000 years."

Dr Teixeira said: "The research corroborates previous studies that the Denisovans were in Island Southeast Asia, and that modern humans did not interbreed with more divergent human groups in the region. This opens two equally exciting possibilities: either a major discovery is on the way, or we need to re-evaluate the current fossil record of Island Southeast Asia."

"Whichever way you choose to look at it, exciting times lie ahead in palaeoanthropology."

Credit: 
University of Adelaide

Total knee replacement a cost-effective treatment for patients with knee osteoarthritis

Knee osteoarthritis is a painful condition that affects over 14 million U.S. adults, many of whom have extreme obesity, defined by body mass index (BMI) greater than 40kg/m2. Total knee replacement (TKR) is often recommended to treat advanced knee osteoarthritis, but surgeons may be hesitant to operate on patients with extreme obesity due to concerns about the increased risks of tissue infection, poor wound healing and higher risk of implant failure. Using an established, validated and widely published computer simulation called the Osteoarthritis Policy (OAPol) Model, researchers from Brigham and Women's Hospital, together with collaborators from Yale and Boston University Schools of Medicine, quantified the tradeoff between the benefits and adverse events, taking into consideration costs of forgoing versus pursuing TKR. They found that across older and younger age groups, TKR is a cost-effective treatment for these patients. Findings are published in Annals of Internal Medicine.

"People with extreme obesity experience substantial pain reduction from TKR, leading to meaningful improvements in quality-adjusted life expectancy. High BMI should not serve as a barrier for people seeking this procedure," said corresponding author Elena Losina, PhD, a founding director of the Policy and Innovation eValuation in Orthopedic Treatments Center and a co-director of the Brigham's Orthopedic and Arthritis Center for Outcomes Research. "From a health policy perspective, this operation offers a very good value for the dollars spent."

The computer model used by the researchers, OAPol, combines clinical and economic data from national datasets to forecast the clinical course of patients who decide to receive or forgo TKR. In the model, each treatment choice is associated with benefits (improvements in pain leading to better quality of life), drawbacks (surgery complications, continuous pain reducing quality of life) and costs. The model tallies the data from a large number of patients to calculate an incremental cost-effectiveness ratio of TKR, calculated as dollars for quality adjusted life year (QALY) gained. The researchers reported favorable cost-effectiveness ratios of $35,200 and $54,100 per QALY for patients younger and older than 65 years, respectively. The researchers noted that most patients with extreme obesity and advanced knee osteoarthritis considering TKR are in the younger age range. These data, they suggest, may help to diminish concerns regarding the value of TKR in these patients.

"Instead of questioning whether or not to do surgery for people with extreme obesity, the conversation should be about how to accommodate these patients and provide accurate information about what to expect post-surgery," Losina said. "Ultimately, this study raises the question of how to do the operation in a way that addresses all of the challenges that may arise. This is a discussion that should take place between individual patients and physicians, discussing all the risks, complications, and benefits as well as considerations of operating room accommodations that would optimize the work of orthopedic surgeons performing TKR in these patients."

Credit: 
Brigham and Women's Hospital

Fungal species causing candidiasis use distinct infection strategies

image: Level of mitochondrial gene expression and interferon response in human epithelial cells in response to infection with the four Candida species.Increased expression of mitochondrial genes and interferon response was only achieved after direct contact with viable Candida cells, but not when they were inactivated or viable but unable to establish direct contact.

Image: 
IRB Barcelona

Candidiasis is a fungal infection caused by a yeast called Candida. It is a serious global health problem and it can be vaginal, oral or systemic. The latter is the most severe form of infection, as it can lead to death, but vaginal candidiasis infection is the most prevalent, affecting 80% of women at some point in their lives.

Scientists led by Dr. Toni Gabaldón, ICREA researcher and group leader at the Institute for Research in Biomedicine (IRB Barcelona) and the Barcelona Supercomputing Center (BSC), in collaboration with Dr. Bernhard Hube's group at the Hans Knoell Institute and the University of Jena in Germany, have described the various mechanisms used by the fungus Candida to infect the epithelium of the vagina and how human cells respond.

Candidiasis is caused by several species of fungus and the study has focused on the four species that cause 90% of cases: Candida albicans, C. glabrata, C. parapsylasis, and C. tropicalis. The researchers have observed that each species has a distinct infection pattern. However, vaginal epithelial cells respond in the same way to different species and the response is modulated according to the severity of the infection as it progresses.

"Understanding the infection processes and the interaction of the fungus with epithelial cells could contribute to the search for a treatment that anticipates the defence response, making it more effective," explains Dr. Gabaldón, head of the Comparative Genomics laboratory at IRB Barcelona and BSC.

A computational study of genetic patterns of infection and defence

Dr. Gabaldón's group has focused on the computational analysis of gene expression patterns of the different Candida species during infection. In this regard, they have quantified, analysed, and compared the genes that are activated and those that remain silent in both human and fungal cells, when infection by the different species of Candida begins.

"Knowing the genetic pattern that corresponds to the pathological process would allow work on a kit to detect infection," explains Hrant Hovhannisyan, co-first author of the study and PhD student of the Comparative Genomics laboratory.

Cell defence based on mitochondrial DNA

Analysis of the genetic defence response of human vaginal epithelial cells revealed that that it was based mainly on the action of mitochondria, the energy organelle of the cell. The researchers found that the mitochondria and even the cells release their DNA, thereby sending a signal to the immune system cells responsible for neutralising the infection.

"This system had previously been observed as a defence against viral infections and also some bacteria, but it is the first time it has been detected in response to a fungal infection," explains Dr. Gabaldón.

This work was carried out within the framework of an Innovative Training Networks (ITN) project funded within the Marie Sk?odowska-Curie Actions call of the European Commission involving ten research groups from several European countries. "The excellence of the partners and the good environment for collaboration fostered by this type of project have allowed us to develop research with high added-value," says Dr. Gabaldón, who is also the project coordinator.

Credit: 
Institute for Research in Biomedicine (IRB Barcelona)

New genetic links found to rare eye disease

image: An electron microscopy image of human retinal cells, which were analyzed in a new study on a rare eye disease known as MacTel. The cells were created using induced pluripotent stem cell technology.

Image: 
Kevin Eade, Scott Henderson and Kimberly Vanderpool

LA JOLLA, CA--An analysis of thousands of genomes from people with and without the rare eye disease known as MacTel has turned up more than a dozen gene variants that are likely causing the condition to develop and worsen for a significant share of patients.

The discovery, by a team of scientists from Scripps Research and the Lowy Medical Research Institute, in collaboration with Columbia University in New York and UC San Diego, provides a new avenue to pursue for diagnosis and treatment. It also sheds light on fundamental aspects of metabolism in the retina, a tissue with one of the highest energy demands in the human body. Findings appear today in the journal Nature Metabolism.

"It's exciting to uncover new answers to the many questions surrounding this rare and complex eye disease," says Martin Friedlander, MD, PhD, professor at Scripps Research and president of the Lowy Medical Research Institute in La Jolla. "Although we've known that MacTel has a genetic component, the precise variants had remained elusive. These findings will serve as a springboard for further scientific investigation and as a guide to potential therapeutic targets."

MacTel, short for "macular telangiectasia type 2," is a progressive and debilitating eye disease that occurs in roughly one out of 5,000 people, or about 2 million people worldwide. A disease of the retina, the light-sensing tissue at the back of the eye, MacTel causes a gradual deterioration of central vision, interfering with critical tasks such as reading and driving.

Piecing together the puzzle

For more than 15 years, scientists have collaborated in an international effort, the MacTel Project, to find the cause of MacTel and develop treatments. Earlier studies found patients had low levels of an amino acid called serine in their bloodstream. However, while serine is essential for many biological processes, it was not known at that time to affect eye health.

In 2019, Friedlander and colleagues found the connection. They made a breakthrough discovery that low serine levels were responsible for a buildup of toxic lipids, which cause photoreceptor cells to die. But still, many questions remained. For example, what caused the decline in serine? The investigation continued.

In the new study, Rando Allikmets, PhD, of Columbia University, used an alternative approach to find genetic drivers of disease. Instead of assessing individual mutations in genes, he and his team analyzed groups of mutations, giving them a greater ability to identify disease-causing genes in a small population of people with MacTel.

One gene, PHGDH, had significantly more variants in MacTel patients than those without the disease. The team identified 22 rare variants in PHGDH which, together, account for approximately 3 to 4 percent of MacTel cases. Many more variants likely exist but haven't been found yet--a challenge considering the small patient population with diverse genetic causes.

Implications for other diseases

PHGDH is a key enzyme that enables the body to make serine, and these studies provided the long-sought link to low serine observed in MacTel patients. Its function is essential for the health of neurons in the eye and elsewhere in the body.

Several of the gene variants identified in the study are known to cause rare, severe neuropathies when both of the alleles, or copies of the gene, are affected. In the case of MacTel, only a single allele is affected, resulting in a partial loss of the enzyme function, which leads to retinal degeneration.

Many of these variants in PHGDH were identified for the first time and were predicted to cause defects in the gene, and Friedlander's group worked to confirm this. They directly tested whether each of the multitude of variants identified in MacTel patients are actually harmful to PHGDH function, and found they were.

"The PHGDH gene is essential for the production of serine, which plays a central role in cellular metabolism," says Kevin Eade, PhD, a former Scripps Research postdoctoral associate who is a senior scientist at the Lowy Medical Research Institute. "Through genetic analyses and experiments in human-derived retinal tissue, we were able confirm that even a partial loss of PHGDH function can have a damaging effect on the retina."

The scientists then used human induced pluripotent stem cells to generate specialized retinal cells that contained one of the MacTel-associated PHGDH mutations. They found that a PHGDH mutation in these cells leads to the production of a toxic lipid previously shown to cause MacTel.

Vision for a therapy

By more fully understanding the role of PHGDH in MacTel, scientists are hopeful they can begin to map out potential treatment approaches.

"We still have much to learn about this rare disease, including why systemic changes in serine metabolism leads to retinal degeneration," says Marin Gantner, PhD, senior staff scientist at the Lowy Medical Research Institute and doctoral graduate of Scripps Research. "We have come such a long way in identifying links to the disease, and every step provides new insights that can be leveraged in creating a therapy."

Credit: 
Scripps Research Institute

Study reveals plunge in lithium-ion battery costs

The cost of the rechargeable lithium-ion batteries used for phones, laptops, and cars has fallen dramatically over the last three decades, and has been a major driver of the rapid growth of those technologies. But attempting to quantify that cost decline has produced ambiguous and conflicting results that have hampered attempts to project the technology's future or devise useful policies and research priorities.

Now, MIT researchers have carried out an exhaustive analysis of the studies that have looked at the decline in the prices these batteries, which are the dominant rechargeable technology in today's world. The new study looks back over three decades, including analyzing the original underlying datasets and documents whenever possible, to arrive at a clear picture of the technology's trajectory.

The researchers found that the cost of these batteries has dropped by 97 percent since they were first commercially introduced in 1991. This rate of improvement is much faster than many analysts had claimed and is comparable to that of solar photovoltaic panels, which some had considered to be an exceptional case. The new findings are reported today in the journal Energy and Environmental Science, in a paper by MIT postdoc Micah Ziegler and Associate Professor Jessika Trancik.

While it's clear that there have been dramatic cost declines in some clean-energy technologies such as solar and wind, Trancik says, when they started to look into the decline in prices for lithium-ion batteries, "we saw that there was substantial disagreement as to how quickly the costs of these technologies had come down." Similar disagreements showed up in tracing other important aspects of battery development, such as the ever-improving energy density (energy stored within a given volume) and specific energy (energy stored within a given mass).

"These trends are so consequential for getting us to where we are right now, and also for thinking about what could happen in the future," says Trancik, who is an associate professor in MIT's Institute for Data, Systems and Society. While it was common knowledge that the decline in battery costs was an enabler of the recent growth in sales of electric vehicles, for example, it was unclear just how great that decline had been. Through this detailed analysis, she says, "we were able to confirm that yes, lithium-ion battery technologies have improved in terms of their costs, at rates that are comparable to solar energy technology, and specifically photovoltaic modules, which are often held up as kind of the gold standard in clean energy innovation."

It may seem odd that there was such great uncertainty and disagreement about how much lithium-ion battery costs had declined, and what factors accounted for it, but in fact much of the information is in the form of closely held corporate data that is difficult for researchers to access. Most lithium-ion batteries are not sold directly to consumers -- you can't run down to your typical corner drugstore to pick up a replacement battery for your iPhone, your PC, or your electric car. Instead, manufacturers buy lithium-ion batteries and build them into electronics and cars. Large companies like Apple or Tesla buy batteries by the millions, or manufacture them themselves, for prices that are negotiated or internally accounted for but never publicly disclosed.

In addition to helping to boost the ongoing electrification of transportation, further declines in lithium-ion battery costs could potentially also increase the batteries' usage in stationary applications as a way of compensating for the intermittent supply of clean energy sources such as solar and wind. Both applications could play a significant role in helping to curb the world's emissions of climate-altering greenhouse gases. "I can't overstate the importance of these trends in clean energy innovation for getting us to where we are right now, where it starts to look like we could see rapid electrification of vehicles and we are seeing the rapid growth of renewable energy technologies," Trancik says. "Of course, there's so much more to do to address climate change, but this has really been a game changer."

The new findings are not just a matter of retracing the history of battery development, but of helping to guide the future, Ziegler points out. Combing all of the published literature on the subject of the cost reductions in lithium-ion cells, he found "very different measures of the historical improvement. And across a variety of different papers, researchers were using these trends to make suggestions about how to further reduce costs of lithium-ion technologies or when they might meet cost targets." But because the underlying data varied so much, "the recommendations that the researchers were making could be quite different." Some studies suggested that lithium-ion batteries would not fall in cost quickly enough for certain applications, while others were much more optimistic. Such differences in data can ultimately have a real impact on the setting of research priorities and government incentives.

The researchers dug into the original sources of the published data, in some cases finding that certain primary data had been used in multiple studies that were later cited as separate sources, or that the original data sources had been lost along the way. And while most studies have focused only on the cost, Ziegler says it became clear that such a one-dimensional analysis might underestimate how quickly lithium-ion technologies improved; in addition to cost, weight and volume are also key factors for both vehicles and portable electronics. So, the team added a second track to the study, analyzing the improvements in these parameters as well.

"Lithium-ion batteries were not adopted because they were the least expensive technology at the time," Ziegler says. "There were less expensive battery technologies available. Lithium-ion technology was adopted because it allows you to put portable electronics into your hand, because it allows you to make power tools that last longer and have more power, and it allows us to build cars" that can provide adequate driving range. "It felt like just looking at dollars per kilowatt-hour was only telling part of the story," he says.

That broader analysis helps to define what may be possible in the future, he adds: "We're saying that lithium-ion technologies might improve more quickly for certain applications than would be projected by just looking at one measure of performance. By looking at multiple measures, you get essentially a clearer picture of the improvement rate, and this suggests that they could maybe improve more rapidly for applications where the restrictions on mass and volume are relaxed."

Trancik adds the new study can play an important role in energy-related policymaking. "Published data trends on the few clean technologies that have seen major cost reductions over time, wind, solar, and now lithium-ion batteries, tend to be referenced over and over again, and not only in academic papers but in policy documents and industry reports," she says. "Many important climate policy conclusions are based on these few trends. For this reason, it is important to get them right. There's a real need to treat the data with care, and to raise our game overall in dealing with technology data and tracking these trends."

Credit: 
Massachusetts Institute of Technology