FORT KNOX, Ky., June 6, 2012 – American Soldiers are reaping the rewards of an innovative Army program designed to identify and treat Soldiers at risk of post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) or depression earlier by conducting behavioral health screening at all primary care visits. During the American Psychiatric Association's annual meeting last month, Col. Charles Engel, M.D., M.P.H., described the RESPECT-Mil program and its results to date in his presentation, "Effective Integrated Mental Health & Primary Care Services in the U.S. Military." Col. Engel is the RESPECT-Mil program director, director of the Department of Defense Deployment Health Clinical Center at Walter Reed National Military Medical Center, and senior scientist at the Center for the Study of Traumatic Stress. He is also associate chair (Research) of the Department of Psychiatry at the Uniformed Services University School of Medicine in Bethesda, Md.
"Making behavioral health screening as standard as a blood pressure check helps defuse any perceived stigma around seeking help for symptoms of PTSD or depression," said Col. Engel. "Early intervention ensures Soldiers get effective help sooner while reducing the use of clinical services for related symptoms like back pain or accidents and emergency room visits from hazardous drinking."
Since 2007, about 63,000 Soldiers – accounting for 3 percent of all primary care visits – have been diagnosed with a previously unrecognized behavioral health need and received treatment. So far, results have been positive. Program data between August 2009 and December 2010 shows PTSD remissions overall have doubled over time, meaning that twice as many patients (starting at less than 10 percent and rising to more than 20 percent) experienced a clinically significant reduction in self-assessed PTSD symptom severity scores to below 27 on the PTSD checklist (PCL) over eight weeks or more. Likewise, RESPECT-Mil data shows that as the number of contacts a care coordinator has with a patient rises, the PTSD and depression severity scores trend downwards in a clinically significant way – regardless of treatment method.
RESPECT-Mil has been rolled out in 88 of the Army's 96 targeted primary care clinics worldwide, with the remainder expected to be online by July. Approximately 100,000 behavioral health screenings now take place in these clinics each month – a rate expected to continue rising as clinics and providers gain experience. Participating clinics follow a three-component model*, with a care coordination manager ensuring continuity of care for the patient and ongoing communication between the primary care provider and a behavioral health specialist. The care coordinator follows up with patients at regular intervals, raising any patient concerns with their providers and ensuring patients follow their treatment plans.
A core aspect of the RESPECT-Mil program is the care coordinators' use of a secure, web-based care management platform for following patients called FIRST-STEPS. Care coordinators enter assessments and schedule appointments, while behavioral health providers use it to review case loads. The most acute cases receive immediate attention. The system also automatically flags patient records that don't show clinically significant improvement after eight weeks for review so providers may adjust treatment plans in a timely way, consistent with treatment guidelines. RESPECT-Mil also offers primary care providers web-based training on how to diagnose and treat PTSD and depression.
"RESPECT-Mil has improved our clinic's efficiency in diagnosing and treating Soldiers with behavioral health concerns," said Melissa Molina, M.D., a family practice physician at Fort Bliss in El Paso, Texas. "We've had a significant reduction in the severity of symptoms of PTSD and depression in our patients. Because most Soldiers screen negative, 90 percent of clinic visits require no added provider time. But in cases where a Soldier does need attention, RESPECT-Mil gives us a proven, effective process to follow."
The Army continues to refine the RESPECT-Mil program to drive even better patient outcomes. Planned enhancements include a stepped approach of psychosocial modalities and telephone-based cognitive-behavioral therapy. Also under development is a five-year, randomized controlled trial in 18 clinics comparing the current approach to a modified approach that Col. Engel's RESPECT-Mil team hopes will offer even greater benefits for patients in need. The Army also expects to expand availability of the program to all military health system beneficiaries (not only Soldiers, but also their families) over the next year as part of the move to Patient Centered Medical Homes.
Better than nothing but
Better than nothing but still does little to overcome the perceived stigma of PTSD and the barriers this provides to actual diagnosis and treatment. A stepped approach pf psychological modalities sounds like a good direction except there are not nearly enough nor will there ever be, according to the National Center for PTSD, qualified mental health professionals to deliver any of the modalities. The problems of stigma, geographic access, cost and availability of mental health resources have yet to be overcome but their are new web-based confidential and inexpensive interventions like ptsdstress.com that hold significant promise.
Posted for COL Charles
Posted for COL Charles Engel
Thanks very much for your response. Stigma is precisely a key reason we have
initiated this approach. For example, our best estimate of the median time
to first treatment in people with PTSD nationally (in civilian care) is 12
years. Fifty percent of those in the Army who are affected with depression
or anxiety including PTSD say that they believe seeking mental health
services will adversely effect their career, while less than 25% report
receiving any specialist care for the problem in the previous year. The
RESPECT-Mil approach is designed to front-load the care system so that
soldiers don't have to go to a specialist -- they are given the added option
of "raising their hand" and asking for help in the primary care setting.
While less than 20% of soldiers seek mental health services in the average
year, 90-95% will seek primary care services (approximately 3.5 primary care
visits a year).
RESPECT-Mil does not attempt to be a panacea -- it is not. That said, it
saves lives by getting those who need care added options for getting that
care and it helps to give people assistance in getting engaged with the care
that is most suitable for them in a timely fashion. As an aside, major
efforts are underway now to insure that every primary care clinic is staffed
with a specialist to improve access to specialist resources. By our
estimate, about 50% of RESPECT-Mil practicing primary care clinics have one
now, and this ratio will only improve in the next year or two.
We aren't there yet, but we continue to push hard to make services better
for those who serve and make sacrifices for all of us. As an aside, with the
implementation of the Patient Centered Medical Home, the Army will be
expanding these services to all adult beneficiaries, recognizing that
families serve right along with their loved ones.
Again, thanks very much for your thoughtful and well placed comments.
Respectfully,
~Chuck
Col. Engel, with all due
Col. Engel, with all due respect, one thing I have learned after providing therapy for 15 years is that people are not forthcoming with their symptoms right away. This is even more of a predominant factor with the military, for one reason being the severity of symptoms of Post Traumatic Stress Disorder and another being the stigma of being labeled with this diagnosis. I have a great deal of respect for you in coming up with a system to help our military but I am suspecting that a self assessment in lieu of ongoing therapy is not going to be affective in the long run. It is very easy to deny symptoms on an assessment. I agree with the above responder that the need for qualified mental health providers to treat our military is paramount to any future healing. What we need to be doing is getting these qualified mental health professionals on board. To date, the DOD will not allow Licensed Professional Counselors to treat active military. Although the American Counseling Association continues to lobby and it was passed in 2006 to recognize counselors within the VA Centers, they continue to post jobs only for social workers. And only social workers and LMFT's are allowed to practice with active military. This is the question to be pondered and resolved. We need to fill the lack of availability of professional and qualified therapists for our military. We owe that much to them! There is also another online therapy center called COPETODAY.COM.
Post new comment